Keep the Information Flowing
Small contributions go a long way. Your donation to Consumer Action, a 501 (c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization, can help us cover the cost of research, writing, and translation of our materials. To keep our services free for those who need them. Select an amount to give.
Protecting yourself from debt collection lawsuits
This guide helps consumers understand how to communicate with a debt collector, what their rights and options are when faced with a debt collection lawsuit, steps to take to try to avoid legal action, where to find legal information and advice, the general process of responding to a lawsuit, their rights if they lose the case and how to file a complaint against a collector.
- This publication is part of the Debt Collection training module.
File Name: DebtorsRights.pdf
File Size: 0.37MB
Table of Contents
- Your rights when you owe a debt
- When a debt collector contacts you
- Avoiding debt collection scams
- Communicating with a collector
- Debt collection and your credit report
- Avoiding legal action
- Responding to a lawsuit
- Mandatory arbitration
- Preparing for the hearing
- If you lose the case
- Free and low-cost legal help
- Filing a complaint
If you are at risk of being sued for an unpaid debt or you are already facing a lawsuit filed by a debt collector, you need to know your rights and options.
Federal and state laws regulate what collectors can and can’t do.
In some cases, these laws even can lead to a debt collection case being dismissed or settled in your favor.
This guide can help you understand:
- What your rights and options are when faced with a debt collection lawsuit or the possibility of one;
- How to communicate with a debt collector;
- The steps you can take to try to avoid legal action;
- The general process of responding to a lawsuit;
- What can happen if you lose the case;
- Where to find free or low-cost legal help; and
- Where to file a complaint if your rights have been violated.
This guide is for general informational purposes only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. It is highly recommended that you contact a qualified attorney experienced in the laws of your state to obtain advice about local court procedures and particular issues pertaining to your own situation.
Your rights when you owe a debt
All U.S. consumers have equal rights under federal laws governing debt collection. Most states also have their own laws on debt collection. These are often the same as the federal protections, but some states provide additional or stronger protections.
The main federal law that governs how collectors can do business is the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). Enforced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), this law prohibits debt collectors from using unfair, abusive or deceptive tactics when collecting debts. Under the law, debt collectors must do certain things (for example, send written notification of the debt and cease collection efforts until they’ve mailed requested verification of the debt), can do certain things (contact you at work unless you tell them not to, for example) and cannot do certain things (like call you at certain hours, contact you at times or places you tell them are inconvenient or say they will take legal action against you if they can’t or won’t).
The FDCPA applies only to debt collectors. This includes collection agencies working on behalf of a creditor, lawyers who regularly collect debts, and companies that buy delinquent debts and try to collect them (debt buyers). It generally doesn’t apply to the original creditor (the company from whom you borrowed the money). It covers the collection of mortgages, credit cards, medical debts, and other debts mainly for personal, family or household purposes. It doesn’t apply to business-related debts.
Most states have their own laws that govern debt collection practices, and some may be even stronger than the federal FDCPA. For example, California’s Fair Debt Collection Practices Act covers more types of collectors, including original creditors collecting debts on their own behalf.
You can find your state’s fair debt collection laws, if any, at the Nolo website and the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse website. You also can contact your state attorney general’s office to learn more about the laws in your state.
State law also determines the statute of limitations (deadline for legal action) on different types of debt. A debt becomes “time-barred” when the statute of limitations runs out—in other words, the collector did not sue you before the deadline. Once the collector misses that deadline, it no longer has the right to sue you for payment. That doesn’t mean you don’t owe the debt or that the collector has to stop trying to get you to pay. (Under the FDCPA, however, you can send a letter to the collector demanding it stop contacting you.) If the collector has reported the debt to credit bureaus, it also doesn’t mean that the unpaid debt will be removed from your credit report. Derogatory (negative) information is allowed to remain on your credit report for seven years; a personal bankruptcy for 10 years.
Learn more in the FTC’s fact sheet "Time-Barred Debts." You can check your state’s statutes of limitations on the Bankrate website or at Nolo.com. Learn about how the statute of limitations is calculated (in other words, when the clock starts ticking) and in what cases it might be suspended in Nolo’s “Calculating the Statute of Limitations." Keep in mind that these deadlines do not apply to federal or state tax bills, federally guaranteed student loans or spousal or child support.
Some states require collectors to be licensed. If a debt collector wins a lawsuit against you without a required license, the judgment could be voided. You can find out if collectors have to be licensed in your state from the state attorney general’s office. (Debt collectors need only a general business license to operate in California.)
Most states impose a cap on interest rates—a “usury law” that prohibits lenders from charging exorbitant interest rates. If a loan exceeds the state’s maximum allowed interest rate, the lender could be fined, a portion of the finance charges could be erased or the contract could be deemed unenforceable. You can find a list of state rate limits at LendingKarma.com. Unfortunately, usury laws do not apply to certain types of debt (business loans, for example) or to banks, savings and loans, or credit unions—and, therefore, credit cards. Under federal law, these lenders are allowed to charge interest rates and fees greater than those permitted under applicable state law. Whether a debt buyer (a collector that buys unpaid debts for a fraction of the balance due and tries to collect on them) can continue to charge an interest rate that exceeds the state’s usury cap after it purchases the debt from a bank or other exempt lender is another question. It is best to contact an attorney for information and advice on this.
When a debt collector contacts you
To protect your privacy, a collector who contacts you by phone must verify your identity before revealing information about your debt. Once they have confirmed that you are the right person, they should tell you the purpose of the call and the fact that they are a collector. If asked, the collector must give you the company’s name, address, phone number and website address. If you have doubts about the legitimacy of the call, or you do not want to verify your identity by phone, you can tell the collector that you want written notice of the debt sent to the address it has on record before you will discuss it.
Within five days of first contacting you, the collector must send you a written “validation notice.” This document contains information about the debt, including the amount, fees and interest accrued, and the name of the creditor. It also contains an explanation of your consumer rights, including the right to dispute the debt. If debt collectors do not send you this validation notice within five days but continue to pursue you for the debt, they have violated the FDCPA and you have the right to sue them.
To retain your rights, you must dispute the debt, request verification of the debt (information that indicates you owe it) and/or request the name and address of the original creditor in writing within 30 days of receiving the validation notice. (This deadline is why it is so important to not ignore collection efforts by a legitimate collector.) There is no deadline by which the collector has to respond, but collection efforts must stop until a response has been sent. The collector can restart collections after responding with the information you requested and/or verification that you owe the debt. If you miss the 30-day deadline, the collector can assume the debt is valid (does not have to verify it) and continue collection efforts during the 30 days and after. However, you may dispute the debt at any time, even if it does not cause collection activities to stop. (The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau offers templates for five types of letter that you can customize and send to a collector to dispute a debt, request more information or specify how you want to be contacted.)
Reasons to dispute a debt include:
- The debt is the result of identity theft.
- You have been mistaken for someone else.
- It is a medical debt that should have been paid by an insurance company, Medicaid or Medicare, etc.
- You don’t agree with the amount of the debt.
- The debt is much larger than what you really owe due to high fees and penalty interest that has been added by the collector.
- You have already paid or settled the debt.
- The debt is too old (time-barred). (If you don’t know the statute of limitations on the debt, ask the collector directly. If you do get an answer, it must be the truth. You also can ask what the collector shows as the date of your last payment. This helps determine when the statute of limitations countdown started. If a debt is time-barred and you don’t intend to pay it, you might want to make a written request asking the collector to stop contacting you about it. Do not acknowledge that you owe the debt or make a payment—this could extend or revive the statute of limitations.)
While many collection efforts begin with a phone call, not all do. You have the same rights when the collector’s initial contact is in writing. If you receive a collection letter in the mail, read it carefully. Unless you have reason to believe the letter is a fake, you should respond. Do not ignore collection letters!
Learn more at the CFPB’s "Are there laws that limit what debt collectors can say or do?" webpage and in Consumer Action’s "When a collector calls: An insider’s guide to responding to debt collectors."
Always keep copies and proof of your communications with the collector. Acceptable proof can be email responses, fax confirmations or return receipts for certified mail.
Avoiding debt collection scams
While many debt collection calls are legitimate, many are scams by imposters attempting to collect on “zombie” or “phantom” debts—debts that don't exist because they are paid off, discharged, forgiven, time-barred (beyond the statute of limitations) or entirely made up. Victims often pay up out of fear that they might actually owe the debt and will suffer serious consequences for not paying. Or, the scammer seeks personal information that can be used to commit identity theft.
Signs that a debt collection call might be a scam include:
- The caller isn’t able to provide your name, address and the last four digits of your Social Security number.
- The caller requests your full Social Security number, complete birthdate or other sensitive personal information.
- The caller refuses to provide information about the collection agency or the debt.
- You don’t recognize the debt.
- The caller claims to be from a government agency, such as the IRS, and tells you to wire money or put money on a reloadable prepaid card and provide the code (a government agency will never ask you to do this).
- The caller harasses you, threatens you with arrest, uses profanity or refuses to let you speak to a manager.
- The caller says you must pay up immediately, or else.
- The caller does not send you a written validation notice.
Just because you don’t recognize the name of the company doesn’t mean it’s a scam. Debts are sometimes legally sold, customer service providers change (especially for mortgages and student loans) and companies (especially banks) are bought by other companies. Also, debt collectors often go by different corporate names in the states they are licensed in because their own company names are too similar to businesses already licensed in that state.
Every written collection attempt must contain the name, address and phone number of the collection agency that is contacting you. Use this information to do an online search to check that the agency is legitimate. In the meantime, until you have confirmed that the caller represents a legitimate collection agency and is contacting you about a legitimate debt you owe:
- Refuse to discuss (or pay) the debt until you receive a written notice about the debt and the collection agency.
- Do not provide sensitive personal or financial information, such as your bank account, credit card or Social Security number.
- If the caller claims to be from a government agency, look up the official number for the collection company and call to confirm. Don’t assume a call is coming from the number displayed on your caller ID—scammers use technology to disguise themselves.
- If you think the debt might be legitimate, contact the original creditor to confirm it has transferred or sold your debt to the collection agency that called you.
Communicating with a collector
Once you have determined that the caller is a real debt collector and that the debt is legitimate, it’s time to have a discussion. You do have the right to ask the collector to stop contacting you, but avoiding a legitimate collector’s calls or letters could push them to take more drastic measures, such as filing a lawsuit. (You can ask for calls to cease and that future communications be by mail.)
While it may not be a good idea to stop communicating with a legitimate collector entirely, you do have the right to tell the collector when you prefer to be contacted. A debt collector cannot contact you at inconvenient times or places. Be sure to put your request in writing. Collectors may not contact you at work if you tell them (orally or in writing) that you're not allowed to get calls there. (While written notice is not required in this case, it’s wise to follow up with a letter so you’ll have a record of your request.)
If debt collectors know that an attorney is representing you, they must contact the attorney instead of you if they have or are easily able to find the attorney’s name and contact information. (You should provide it, if necessary.)
During all your communications, stay calm and respectful—the discussion is more likely to go in your favor. It is a violation of the FDCPA for the collector to use abusive language or profanity; you shouldn’t either.
Keep detailed notes of all your communications with the collector, including date, time and content of the discussion. This will help you recall what was discussed and will serve as a record if the collector does anything to violate the FDCPA.
Debt collection and your credit report
Another important right for all consumers is the right to get your credit report from each of the three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian and TransUnion) for free every 12 months at AnnualCreditReport.com. This can be helpful in determining what debts you owe and their status. Not all collectors report debts to the credit bureaus, but it pays to check. You can glean a lot from your credit report, including, in some cases, who the original creditor was, when the debt was transferred or sold to a collector, what the current balance is, when the last payment was, etc. If the debt does not appear on your credit report, it could still be legitimate, but you should get proof of that.
If you have disputed the debt, the collector is not allowed to report it to a credit reporting agency unless and until it verifies the debt. If it has already been reported, the collector has to notify the credit reporting agencies that the debt has been disputed. After verifying the debt, the debt collector can report it, but only as a “disputed” debt. It is a violation of the FDCPA and the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) for a collector to report a debt that it knows, or should know, is false.
Avoiding legal action
If you are sued by a debt collector, you will be served with an order to appear in court (summons). At this point, it’s highly recommended that you consult with an attorney.
Since debt collectors would prefer to receive their money without having to take legal action, sometimes the best way to avoid a lawsuit is to communicate with the collector. The goal would be to assure the collector that you intend to repay the debt or to let the company know that you can’t pay the debt. (Since predicting the likely outcome of a suit can be complicated, it’s wise to consult with an attorney before assuming you can’t be made to pay because you have no income or assets or because you believe your income is protected. See the “If you lose the case” section below for more information.)
If you do have income or financial assets that a court could order be taken to satisfy the debt, you might be better off working out a voluntary repayment plan or a settlement. A settlement means you would pay less than the full balance but the debt would be considered paid in full. But again, this is a crucial decision that is better made with the counsel of an experienced credit counseling agency or a debt collection attorney.
When trying to negotiate a settlement or repayment plan, it helps to know whether you are dealing with a collector working on behalf of the original creditor or a “debt buyer,” who purchases unpaid debts for pennies on the dollar and then keeps whatever payment they are able to collect. Debt buyers sometimes are more flexible when it comes to accepting lower payments or settling for a smaller percentage of the original debt. One way to know if you are dealing with a debt buyer is that on your credit report your original creditor shows a $0 balance owed to them—this means your account was sold. (Despite the $0 balance to the creditor, your credit report will still reflect a “charge-off.”) You also can ask the creditor if it sold your account. Or you can research the company trying to collect from you online to find out if it is a third-party collector or a debt buyer. ACA International, an association of collectors, provides tools and information for consumers at its “Ask Doctor Debt” website.
Before offering a settlement or repayment plan, analyze your finances to make sure that whatever you propose fits your budget. The collector might be quicker to sue you if you miss agreed-upon payments. A good way to figure out what you can afford is to consult with a non-profit credit counseling agency. A credit counselor can go over your budget and help you determine what, if anything, you can manage to pay. Credit counselors also can provide useful information about dealing with specific debt collection issues.
In addition to providing general information and budgeting assistance, credit counseling agencies also offer something called a debt management plan (DMP), under which your monthly unsecured debt payments would be consolidated into a single payment that you make to the agency. The agency would then disburse the funds to your creditors. There typically is a fee for this (up to $50/month), but some agencies will waive it if your income is low. The benefit of the DMP to consumers is the potentially reduced monthly payments, reduced interest rates, waived fees and agreement to hold off on legal action that the credit counseling agency can often (not always) obtain on its clients’ behalf. Many creditors and some collectors accept DMP payments, and typically agree to hold off on legal action as long as they receive the promised monthly amount. But be aware that missing even a single payment could be enough for them to initiate a lawsuit against you. Find a non-profit credit counseling agency at the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) website or by calling 800-388-2227.
If you do come to an agreement with the collector, ask for it to be put in writing, on the collector’s letterhead, and a copy sent to you. It should mention the name of the original creditor. Do not make any payment until you receive the agreement. And do not give the collector permission to access your bank account, either through automated debits or by providing your debit card number—once the money comes out of your account, it will be difficult or impossible to get back, even if you believe the collector took too much or took it on the wrong date. Send payments by check, or initiate electronic payments using your bank’s online bill pay function.
Visit Nolo’s “Debt Settlement & Negotiation with Creditors” webpage to link to a number of articles that will prepare you to discuss your repayment options with a creditor or debt collector. Some tips offered include hinting at the possibility of bankruptcy, and starting very low (around 15 percent of the balance), with the aim of settling for 50 percent or less. It also helps to gather some cash before starting negotiations because you typically can get a lower settlement if you can transfer the funds immediately.
Be aware that making any payment or even promising to make a payment on a time-barred debt could reset the statute of limitations. Nolo cautions against accidentally waiving, extending or reviving the statue of limitations.
If your debt is too large to pay and you don’t see any way out, filing for bankruptcy could be an option to consider—either before or after you are sued. A collector cannot continue collecting on an account while the court is considering the bankruptcy case, and it cannot try to collect on a debt that has been discharged (eliminated) in bankruptcy. The fear of losing the ability to collect any part of a debt because of bankruptcy sometimes makes collectors more amenable to repayment plans or settlement proposals.
Though there is a lot of “do-it-yourself” bankruptcy information available, don’t try to file bankruptcy without a lawyer. A mistake could result in a debt not getting discharged, which means you would still be required to pay it. Consumer Action offers a general guide to personal bankruptcy, which includes resources for finding a bankruptcy attorney.
Responding to a lawsuit
This guide offers general information, not advice. If you are sued, we urge you to seek the advice of an attorney, as you easily could overlook technical aspects of the case and lose important rights.
If you can’t come to a payment or settlement agreement with the collector, you could be subject to a lawsuit, garnishment of your earned income or seizure of your assets (in addition to continued collection efforts and negative credit reporting). If you haven’t done so already, you should contact an attorney or legal advice resource for guidance regarding your situation. Don’t wait until your case has gone to court to get legal help. (See the "Free and low-cost legal help" section of this guide for information about finding legal advice and representation when you can’t afford to pay for it.)
If a debt collector sues you, it must notify you in writing in two documents—the summons (tells you what you must do and by what date) and the complaint (tells you who is suing you, why and for how much). (In some places, the summons and the complaint may be combined into a single document.) You should never ignore a lawsuit. If you're sued by a debt collector, you should respond, either personally or through an attorney, or you should make a conscious, informed decision, based on the facts of your case and the advice of a qualified attorney, not to respond. When responding, you must do so by the deadline given in the court papers to preserve your rights. The court where the complaint is filed determines whether you have to be “served” (delivered) the lawsuit documents in person or can be served by mail. In many states, you will receive notice of the suit by certified mail. (Refusing to accept the letter will not stop the lawsuit.)
An "answer" is a formal, written statement of your defense to the lawsuit. Depending on the facts of your case, answers might include, but are not limited to, stating that the debt is not yours, contesting the amount the collector says you owe, questioning the collector’s right to sue to collect the debt (perhaps because it is beyond the statute of limitations), or saying that you do not know if the statements in the complaint are true. Answering the lawsuit puts the debt collector in the position of having to produce evidence that proves to the court you owe the debt. There may be other ways of responding to a lawsuit—for example, filing a motion or a counterclaim. A lawyer can explain the legal implications of each type of response and help you determine which one, if any, would be best in your case. (In some cases, it may be to your advantage not to respond, but this strategy is best determined with the guidance of a lawyer.)
If you ignore a court action, there’s a possibility that a “default” judgment will be entered against you for the amount the creditor or debt collector claims you owe. A court also may award the collector additional money to cover its collection and/or legal costs. A judgment gives the debt collector stronger tools to collect the money you owe, such as garnishment of your wages or seizure of money in your bank account. This is one reason why it is so important to speak to an attorney before responding to a lawsuit.
If you dispute the debt or the amount owed, do it before the court makes a judgment. A judgment is a court order, and only the court can change it. It's very difficult to get a judgment changed or set aside once the case is over. While you may have options to have the default judgment “vacated” (voided) for certain reasons, you are much better off avoiding a judgment than trying to fight one after the case has been decided.
Active duty servicemembers have some important added protections against default judgments and garnishments under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA). Learn more at Military.com and SaveAndInvest.org. Servicemembers being sued should consult their local JAG office.
Some collectors file lawsuits knowing that they don’t have enough evidence to prove the defendant owes the debt. Because few people respond to the notice of a lawsuit—a potentially big mistake—collectors may count on winning by default. If you file an answer, it is possible that the collector will attempt to negotiate with you to avoid a lawsuit it can’t prove. If this doesn’t happen, it could be because the collector feels confident that it has the needed proof to win the case, and this may be your last chance to negotiate. Speak to an attorney or credit counselor to weigh your options.
Some collectors also sue despite the statute of limitations being expired. A court could still award a judgment against you if you are sued but don’t show up and raise the age of the debt as a defense. (There are no time limits on federal or state tax bills, federally guaranteed student loans or spousal or child support.)
There have been many cases in which collectors go to court without actually having served the summons to the person being sued. If you learn of a default judgment against you in a lawsuit you were not notified about, you have a strong legal defense to stop any efforts to collect on the judgment. Consult a consumer attorney specializing in debt collection immediately.
You have the right to bring a claim against the plaintiff (the person or company suing you)—for example, if the debt is for a product that injured you or caused damage, or if you believe the plaintiff has violated the FDCPA. (Depending on your case and/or court, you may be able to state this in your answer.) Usually you must pay a fee when you file a counterclaim. You can get general information about court rules, fees, terminology, procedures and practices from an attorney or by contacting the court clerk, but the clerk cannot give you legal advice.
Learn more about responding to a debt collection lawsuit at the CFPB’s "What should I do if a creditor or debt collector sues me?" webpage; at Nolo’s “Credit Lawsuits: How the Case Begins” webpage; in Nolo’s “Represent Yourself in Court” book; and at Nolo’s “Defenses and Counterclaims to Creditor Lawsuits” webpage.
Arbitration is a way of resolving disputes in which an entity outside of the court system decides the outcome of a disagreement. There is non-binding arbitration, sometimes ordered by a court, and there is binding mandatory arbitration that is required under many credit card, loan (but not mortgage) and consumer service agreements. These pre-dispute mandatory arbitration clauses require that any future disputes between the company and a consumer be heard by an arbitrator rather than by a judge in court. The arbitrator’s decision is binding, whether the consumer shows up for the hearings or not.
Whether or not an arbitration clause included in the contract (agreement) you accepted when you entered into a relationship with the original creditor or service provider is valid after the debt is handed off or sold to a debt collector depends on the language in the agreement, and could depend on the relationship between the collector and the original creditor. It is advisable to have an attorney review whether an arbitration clause in your particular credit agreement is void or valid once it is transferred or sold to a collector, or whether it is unenforceable for any other reason. (Mandatory binding arbitration overwhelmingly favors creditors, which is a good reason to try to have the case heard in court.)
If the debt collector takes its case against you to arbitration, you will receive a notice. As with a regular lawsuit, you should not simply ignore the deadlines and requirements outlined in the notice. If you can’t afford the arbitration fee, ask if it is possible to apply for a fee waiver. If the arbitrator’s office is far from you and you can’t afford to travel, ask if there is an option to change the hearing to a conference call or if it can be done through mail or email. Even though you don’t have to have a lawyer in arbitration, you should consult an attorney to protect your rights.
During the arbitration, you and the collector each have a chance to tell your side of the story. If the arbitrator decides you owe the money, it will issue an “award” to the debt collector, who must then go to a judge and seek a court judgment. If the judgment is granted, the collector can pursue garnishment to have money taken from your paycheck or bank account.
You have the right to “challenge” the award, but the time frame and your reasons for doing so are limited, so seek the advice of a lawyer.
In court-ordered arbitration, the arbitrator is assigned by the court or chosen by the two sides. Fees usually are capped and may even be waived if they are unaffordable. Unlike in the mandatory “pre-dispute” arbitration hearings required by many companies, the arbitrator’s decision in court-ordered arbitration is non-binding, which means that either side can reject the decision and have the case go back before a judge.
Preparing for the hearing
The summons you receive will tell you where the case will be heard. You and/or your attorney should arrive prepared and on time. Consider getting advice from an attorney to determine exactly what documents to bring. These might include, for example:
- All correspondence you have received from or sent to the collector, including copies of letters, printouts of email messages and notes of all phone conversations, including whether the collector was disrespectful or harassed you with repeated calls;
- Records of who the collector has contacted (your employer, for example) about the debt;
- Any other documentation that supports your case, which might include a credit report, statements, canceled checks or documents that show the debt is too old to sue for (time-barred, or past the statute of limitations), doesn’t belong to you, is in the wrong amount, or that demonstrates you have made a good faith effort to repay the debt; and
- Records verifying your income and assets if you are claiming exemption from garnishment.
Depending on your state, if the case is heard in small claims court, you might not be allowed to have an attorney present with you. Learn about your options in Nolo’s “If You Get Sued in Small Claims Court.”
It is possible that you will have a last-minute opportunity to try to work out a settlement or repayment plan with the collector just before the case is heard. Make sure any agreement is presented “on the record” during the hearing, and that you receive a copy of the agreement. Do not agree to any repayment plan that you aren’t sure you can fulfill.
If you lose the case
If the collector wins the case, the court will enter a judgment against you, which states how much you owe. (In the case of arbitration, the collector will take the award to a court and ask it to confirm it.) The collector has a certain number of years to collect—the exact period varies by state, as listed in an excerpt from Nolo’s "Everybody's Guide to Small Claims Court.” Most states allow creditors to renew the judgment, and some allow them to renew it over and over, essentially making the judgment permanent. Learn more about how long a judgment can last at the Nolo website.
If you don’t pay in full or by negotiating a payment plan, the collector may be able to have money taken from your paycheck or bank account under a garnishment order. The collector may even be able to get a lien against real estate you own. (A lien typically prevents you from selling the property until the underlying debt has been paid and removed, though some property owners may be able to take legal steps to get it removed by, say, claiming the property is exempt, filing bankruptcy or making a request to the court. Learn more about judgment liens at the Nolo website.)
Regardless of the amount of the judgment, the law places limits on what can be taken from you. Under federal law, a creditor can only garnish 25 percent of your net wages (gross wages minus taxes and mandatory deductions) or the amount that exceeds 30 times the federal minimum wage ($7.25 per hour in 2016), whichever is less. State law may offer even greater protection. For example, in California, the lesser of 25 percent of weekly disposable earnings or 50 percent of the amount by which earnings exceed 40 times the state minimum wage ($10 per hour in 2016), or local minimum wage, if higher, is subject to levy. Typically, more of your earnings can be garnished for certain types of debt, such as taxes and spousal or child support. Learn more in AllLaw.com’s "How Much of My Wages Can Be Garnished?" That page also provides a link to Nolo’s list of state wage garnishment laws.
Income from government benefits (Social Security, VA, SSI, etc.) is further protected. In some cases, it can’t be touched at all, while in other cases it could be garnished to some degree to pay certain types of debts, such as child support, alimony, student loans and delinquent taxes. Whether your government benefits can be garnished and to what extent depends on factors such as the laws of your state, the source of the benefits, how they were deposited, how much of them remains in your account and the type of debt you owe. The FTC offers a fact sheet on "Garnishing Federal Benefits," which details not only what types of government benefits are exempt, but also what to do if you receive a notice of garnishment or your bank account has been frozen. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau offers information on the topic in "Your benefits are protected from garnishment" and "Can a debt collector take my Social Security or VA benefits?" The CFPB also offers a sample letter template you can use to tell a collector that your Social Security or VA benefits are protected from garnishment.
If your bank freezes any money in your account, it must send you a notice of garnishment. Then, a judge decides whether the money should be turned over to the debt collector based on factors such as the source of your income and state law. It is very important for the judge to be aware that the source of your balance is government benefits before a decision is made regarding what should be turned over to the collector. Contact a lawyer or legal aid society for help. If you’re a senior, the Center for Elder Rights Advocacy (866-949-2372) can refer you to a local agency that provides free legal help to seniors who qualify. Be aware that even if you are entitled to notification that money in your bank account will be seized, you may not receive the notice in time to avoid bounced-check or non-sufficient funds (NSF) fees on outstanding checks.
Some portion of your personal possessions and equity in a car and/or home is also exempt. Some states limit liens on homes, even if a debt collector has obtained a judgment. If a debt collector is threatening to put a lien on your home, consult an attorney to learn your rights under your state’s laws. Find information about your state’s homestead exemption (the amount of equity in your home that cannot be touched by most creditors) and other exemptions at LegalConsumer.com.
Seek legal advice if your wages are garnished, funds are frozen or removed from your bank account or a lien is placed on your home.
Under federal law, it is illegal for your employer to fire you because of a garnishment for a single debt. But federal law doesn’t protect you from being fired if two judgment creditors attach your wages, or if one judgment creditor attaches your wages to pay two different judgments. However, state law might offer additional protections in the case of multiple judgments. (Nolo offers state law resources that may help you determine your protections in the case of multiple judgments.) You might be able to avoid getting fired by convincing your employer that you are doing your best to clear up the debt as soon as possible.
Collection agencies don't have the legal authority to issue arrest warrants or have you put in jail. However, if a collector has obtained a judgment against you, a judge could issue a warrant for your arrest if you ignore an order to appear in court or do not pay the legal fees stemming from your case, if any. In a handful of states, debt collectors are allowed to seek arrest warrants for debtors if all other collection methods have failed. (In reality, not all counties in those states enforce debt-related warrants.) To protect yourself, always show up when summoned, and seek assistance from a lawyer.
If you learn of a default judgment against you in a case you were not notified about, you have a strong legal defense to stop any efforts to collect on the judgment. Consult an attorney specializing in debt collection immediately.
Free and low-cost legal help
Whether you are considering filing bankruptcy or you need advice or representation for a debt collection lawsuit, there are free and low-cost sources of legal help for those who qualify. (While legal aid organizations provide free legal services to low-income people, know that there aren’t nearly enough legal aid lawyers to serve everyone, so finding the funds to pay for at least an initial consultation with an experienced debt collection attorney may be a wise course.)
The Legal Services Corporation (LSC), an independent non-profit established by Congress in 1974 to provide financial support for civil legal aid to low-income Americans, provides referrals to local legal aid offices for those who cannot afford a private attorney.
The Center for Elder Rights Advocacy (866-949-2372) can refer consumers to a local agency that provides free legal help to seniors who qualify.
Active duty servicemembers have special rights under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA). If you are in the military and need legal help, contact your Armed Forces Legal Assistance Office.
The National Association of Consumer Advocates website (NACA) allows you to search for a qualified attorney in your area. While these attorneys’ services are not necessarily free or low-cost, an attorney might be willing to defend you pro bono (free) if he or she believes the collector is breaking state or federal law, because the collector, if it loses the case, would be responsible for paying your attorney’s fees.
If you don’t qualify for free or low-cost legal help, you can contact a lawyer referral service such as your state or local bar association and ask for an attorney with experience in consumer law, debt collection defense or the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Or ask for referrals from people you know, including any good attorney you have hired before. Some attorneys are willing to forgo upfront payment and charge you only if and when you win your case (contingency fee arrangement) because in an FDCPA case, the court has the power to order that the debt collector pay for your attorney’s fees if you win.
Filing a complaint
If you’re having trouble with a debt collector, submit your complaint directly to the company’s compliance department. If you are not able to resolve the issue directly with the collection agency, you can file a complaint with:
- The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), which regulates the collection industry and shares enforcement of the FDCPA, online or by phone at 855-411-2372
- The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which, along with the CFPB, enforces the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, online or by phone at 877-FTC-HELP
- The Better Business Bureau
- Your state’s attorney general (state-by-state contact information at the National Association of Attorneys General website)
Nolo offers tips in “What to Do If a Bill Collector Crosses the Line." One tip is to send a copy of the FTC/CFPB complaint to the collection agency and the original creditor in hopes of getting them to cancel or negotiate the debt.
If you believe a debt collector has violated the law, you have the right to sue in federal or state court within a year of the date of the violation. If you win, the judge can order the collector to pay your attorney’s fees and maybe even actual damages (such as lost wages or medical expenses). If the debt collector knowingly and purposely violated the law, the court must award you an additional $100 to $1,000. However, you will still owe the debt if it is proven valid. Learn more by visiting the Nolo webpage on “Damages for FDCPA Violations.”
Published / Reviewed Date
Reviewed: October 14, 2016
File Name: DebtorsRights.pdf
File Size: 0.37MB
Consumer Action’s Managing Money Project
This publication was funded by Consumer Action’s Managing Money Project.
© 2014 –2016 Consumer Action. Rights Reserved.
Support Consumer Action
Consumer Help Desk
- Help Desk
- Submit Your Complaints
- Presente su queja
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Links to Consumer Resources
- Consumer Service Guide (CSG)
- Class Action Database
- Consumer Booknotes